Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe

Episode 34: 1970s Baseball Rookies Top 10 List

In this nostalgic and knowledge-packed episode of Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, host Joe Davis returns to the mic with a countdown that’s sure to stir up opinions: the Top 10 Baseball Rookie Cards of the 1970s. From iconic Hall of Famers to underrated gems, Joe reveals which cards made the cut—not just based on value, but on impact, collectability, and long-term hobby relevance.
You’ll hear about the standout careers that shaped the decade, why certain beloved players just missed the top 10 (including a personal favorite), and what sets cards like the 1973 Mike Schmidt and 1975 George Brett apart. Joe also shares cautionary advice for modern collectors chasing today’s prospects, offering timeless insight on why vintage still holds powerful value.
Whether you’re a longtime collector or new to the hobby, this episode delivers sharp takes, hobby history, and plenty of heart.
Tune in and discover which rookie cards from the '70s deserve a place in your collection—and why smart collecting always starts with perspective.

Episode 33: Why Do We Collect? (With Taylor Pruitt)

In this special episode of Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, Taylor steps in for Joe and takes listeners on a thoughtful, nostalgic, and slightly quirky deep dive into one central question: Why do we collect?
Taylor reflects on his own collecting journey, beginning at age five with Topps baseball cards from his grandparents after Little League games. His childhood idol, Chipper Jones (specifically “baby-faced Chipper”), becomes the symbolic heart of his collection, and this nostalgia fuels a broader conversation about the psychology and emotional depth behind why we collect the things we do.
The episode explores:
The psychology of collecting
Historical examples of collecting
The emotional power of nostalgia
The real reason most collectors stay in the hobby
Taylor also challenges listeners to ask deeper questions—not just what someone collects, but why. Whether it’s baby-faced Chipper, Pez dispensers, or Squishmallows, every collection tells a story.

Episode 32: What's Joe Buying?

In this episode of Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, Joe gives listeners an exclusive look at the types of cards he’s actively pursuing in today’s market. Whether it’s for the store, investment purposes, or personal passion, Joe breaks down the key categories that are catching his eye right now.
But this isn’t just a list—it’s a deeper conversation about market shifts, collector trends, and where real long-term value might be hiding. From classics that never go out of style to a few unexpected plays that might surprise you, Joe shares the thought process behind what he buys—and why it matters.
If you're trying to navigate the changing landscape of the hobby, this episode is a must-listen. You’ll walk away with fresh perspective, new ideas, and maybe even a few targets to start hunting for yourself.
Tune in now to hear what Joe’s buying—and what you might want to be looking at next.

Episode 31: Joe's Top 10 List for 1960s Rookie Cards

In this episode of Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, Joe Davis takes you on a journey through his Top 10 rookie cards of the 1960s — a golden era packed with legends, tough pulls, and cards that helped shape the hobby we love. But this isn’t just about value — it’s about historical importance, rarity, and impact on the game.
Joe shares his personal perspective as a longtime collector and dealer, and he puts the disclaimer out loud and clear: “Hey, you're going to disagree with me!”
From high-number cards to iconic rookies, this episode is a must-listen for vintage collectors and baseball fans alike. Plus, Joe shares a few that just missed the cut... for all your ifs, ands, and buts.

Episode 30: An Interview with Jeff Foxworthy (Preview)

And this is just a preview of the full conversation! Catch the full video releasing on Tuesday, June 10th, on the Joe Davis Media YouTube channel or find it on The Joe Davis Show on your favorite podcast platform.Joe Davis Media: www.youtube.com/@joedavismediaThe Joe Davis Show: www.TheJoeDavisShow.podbean.com
In this powerful and entertaining episode, Joe sits down with comedy legend Jeff Foxworthy to talk about faith, family, and finding purpose. Jeff shares how he went from repairing machines at IBM to standing on stage with Johnny Carson — and how encouragement, grit, and grace shaped every step of the way.
You’ll hear:
How Jeff launched his comedy career with $8,000 and 400+ shows in a single year
The life advice from Chick-fil-A’s Truett Cathy that he’s never forgotten
A moving take on Luke 15 and what the prodigal son story reveals about the heart of God
How Jeff balanced rising fame with intentional fatherhood
Why laughter is a holy gift — and how it still fuels his purpose today
Real stories. Real encouragement. Real impact.Don't miss this conversation that will leave you laughing, reflecting, and deeply inspired.

Episode 29: Random Ramblings with Joe

In this refreshingly unfiltered episode of Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, Joe breaks from the usual format to share a rapid-fire rundown of hot-button topics shaking up the hobby right now.
From looming changes in card grading turnaround times to the surprising retail spaces selling sports cards (Ace Hardware, anyone?), Joe dishes out timely insights collectors and dealers won’t want to miss.
With the National Sports Collectors Convention on the horizon, now's the time to stay sharp, strategic, and ahead of the curve. If you're buying, grading, or just love geeking out on cardboard, this episode is your playbook for what's really going on in the hobby.

Episode 28: Buying Collections with Guest Dale Moody

In this must-listen episode of Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, host Joe Davis welcomes back seasoned collector, leader in the dealing-industry, and long-time friend Dale Moody for an unforgettable deep-dive into the world of collection buying—from best practices to bizarre road stories that will feel like hobby magic and make you laugh.
You'll hear:
Insider tips on where and how to find hidden gem collections (even in today’s digital age)
What to never do when you're making a deal—and the hard lessons they learned so you don't have to
A jaw-dropping road trip story involving bolt cutters, a Florida storage unit, and thousands of dollars in Mickey Mantle and Sandy Koufax autographs
Why sometimes it's better to walk away—and how to know when it's not
A frank, old-school take on today’s ultra-modern, high-stakes card market (think PSA 10s, 1-of-1s, and $50K rookie gambles)
How faith and fairness still guide ethical decisions in the hustle of collectibles
Whether you're a buyer, seller, or just a collector at heart, this episode is packed with laugh-out-loud moments, valuable wisdom, and real-life collecting gold. Tune in now to learn how to buy smart, stay honest, and maybe avoid breaking into storage units (even accidentally).If you missed our first episode with Dale Moody (episode 25), go back and give it a listen... you'll be glad you did!

Episode 27: Collecting T206 Cards with Cleve Bosher

This week, Joe Davis is joined again by hobby veteran, vintage expertise, and close friend Cleve Bosher for a deep dive into the iconic T206 White Border set—aka “The Monster.” With nearly four decades of hands-on experience, Cleve unpacks what makes this set so legendary, from stunning lithography and rare back variations to Hall of Fame cards and infamous errors.
You’ll hear stories of big-time finds, fakes, near-completions, and the quirks that keep collectors hooked over a century later.
What’s inside:✅ Why Honus Wagner’s card fetched $7.25 million✅ The mystery behind Eddie Plank and the “Magie” error✅ What makes a Lenox or Drum back so valuable✅ Budget-friendly tips for new T206 collectors
Whether you're deep into vintage cards or just T206-curious, this episode is full of insights, stories, and inspiration for collectors of all levels.
🎧 Tune in now—and if you missed Joe and Cleve's first episode together (looking at you episode 23), it's a must listen!

Episode 26: Joe's Top 10 List (40s & 50s Baseball)

This week on Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, host Joe Davis takes you on a nostalgic ride through hobby history with a bold top 10 list decades in the making. Joe breaks down what he believes are the most historically significant rookie cards from the 1950s — and, as a bonus, shares his top 8 from the limited but legendary 1940s!
From a short-printed Satchel Paige to the mythic 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle, Joe digs into the stories behind the cardboard — the cultural impact, the legends they represent, and why some cards just matter more. Expect some surprises, a few controversial picks (check out #10?), and deep collector wisdom honed from decades in the hobby.
Whether you're a seasoned collector or just love the game, this episode offers rich insight, heartfelt reflection, and a reminder of why these little pieces of cardboard still matter so much.
🎧 Ready to hear which iconic rookie cards made the cut — and which just missed it? Tune in now.

Episode 25: Dealer Spotlight with Dale Moody

This week on Sports Cards & A Cup of Joe, host Joe Davis sits down with longtime friend and  absolute legendary collector Dale Moody for an unforgettable conversation that dives deep into the heart of the hobby.
From flipping comics out of fraternity houses in the ‘70s to uncovering a trunk full of vintage Marvel gold (yes, including Amazing Fantasy #15), Dale shares incredible stories from his decades in the industry — comic books, sports cards, Olympic pins, and even Coca-Cola memorabilia.
You’ll hear:
How a $2,500 comic deal in 1979 kickstarted a lifelong business
The deal that included a real Babe Ruth & Lou Gehrig-signed baseball
The rise of eBay and PSA – and how it reshaped the entire collectibles world
Lessons from the boom-and-bust of sports card trends (and how to avoid hobby burnout)
Why collecting what you love is the key to enjoying the journey
Whether you're a seasoned collector, a nostalgic hobbyist, or just curious how a passion can turn into a profession, this episode is full of wisdom, laughs, and a few “why-did-I-sell-that?!” moments. You can't miss this episode of hanging out with Dale!